What Should I Buy?QuestionCommunity Starter

CPO luxury SUV or brand-new mainstream SUV?

PistonOwner69Community StarterSep 9, 20252023 Audi S5 SportbackTexas
Budget works for either a lightly used luxury SUV or a new mainstream model with a full warranty. I'm more worried about three-to-five-year ownership cost and service downtime than the purchase price. How would you compare them? I'd rather test this logically than start replacing parts.
permalink

6 replies

BoxerRoadie48Community StarterCommunity StarterSep 9, 2025permalink
Insurance and tax belong in the comparison, not as a surprise. Ask for out-the-door on the 2023 Audi S5 with fees, add-ons, and rate on separate lines. I'd rather lose the car than buy a foggy deal. On “new mainstream suv,” that was the fork that mattered for me. This is from a 2023 Audi S5 in Texas. Not gospel, but it saved me a headache. Wrote this up on my lunch break.
ApexGuy71Community StarterCommunity StarterSep 10, 2025permalink
Walk if they won't put it on a buyer’s order. In Texas, insurance quotes flipped a 2023 Audi S5 comparison for me more than the sale price did. Then the comparison gets honest. The universe charges extra for guessing. Worth doing even if the car feels fine right now. Doc fee is the line I'm watching.
CruiseMom94Community StarterCommunity StarterSep 10, 2025permalink
I'd slow the salesperson down here. If one piece looks too good on the 2023 Audi S5, hunt doc fees, accessories, and the APR next. Then the comparison gets honest. I'd want a dollar figure or a measured spec, not 'should be fine.' I'm in no rush to be a hero on it.
ApexGuy71Community StarterCommunity StarterSep 10, 2025permalink
Get the messy numbers in writing first. Keep sale price, trade, and financing split on the 2023 Audi S5 so a “good payment” cannot bury a worse deal. I'd rather lose the car than buy a foggy deal. On “new mainstream suv,” that was the fork that mattered for me. This is from a 2023 Audi S5 in Texas. Parts cannon is a personality type I try to avoid. This is the filter I use when the thread starts repeating itself. That's my plan before I call anyone.
SmoothTechCommunity StarterCommunity StarterSep 10, 2025permalink
That's a good start, but I wouldn't stop there. If one piece looks too good on the 2023 Audi S5, hunt doc fees, accessories, and the APR next. Screenshot the worksheet if you can. Take it or leave it — that's what I'd do. Not letting add-ons ride along because everyone does.
PistonOwner69Community StarterCommunity StarterSep 11, 2025permalink
Update from me: I finally have sale price, fees, and trade on separate lines for the 2023 Audi S5. PPI guy I use is booked until next week, so I'm waiting.
Sign in to reply

Similar discussions